Embedding human right
Getting it into the company’s DNA
- Assigning responsibility for human rights
- Leadership form the top is essential
- Considering the company’s commitment in recruitment
- Talking honestly about human rights
- Training key staff
- Developing incentives and disincentives
- Developing capacity to solve dillemas and respond to unforeseen circumstances
- Common pitfalls to avoid
- Suggestions for SMEs
A policy is just words on paper without action to put it into practice. In order for a company to implement its commitment, respect for human rights needs to become part of the company’s culture or ‘DNA’ – it needs to be an integral part of how it operates. Embedding is about creating the right ‘macro-level’ environment for a policy to be effective in practice. It includes training, performance and accountability structures, tone at the top from senior management and the board, and a sense of shared responsibility for meeting the company’s human rights commitments.
Main companies divisions to be involved in the process
Senior management: Involved in setting targets, incentives and disincentives; fostering a human rights-respecting company culture through the tone from the top; leading necessary change management (with a particular focus on middle management)
Human resources: Helps embed human rights in typical human resources processes, such as recruitment, hiring, training, performance appraisal and dismissal
CSR/sustainability: May provide substantive expertise for the embedding phase; helps design and conduct training
Middle management: Implementing and executing the policy; coaching, supporting and overseeing employees; taking appropriate disciplinary measures when necessary
Communications: May help senior management in setting the tone, informing staff of important developments and disseminating key policies and commitments
Assigning responsibility for human rights
Embedding respect for human rights requires assigning appropriate responsibility for human rights within the company. Initially, a single function or department may need to take the lead in kick-starting the process. Corporate functions like procurement, human resources and sales will also need to be involved to ensure that there is cross-functional support for the embedding process. Ultimately, business operations should take ownership of managing human rights risks with respect to the core activities of the company that they control.
Examples of different companies’ experiences in organising responsibility for human rights can be found in the resources at the end of this section.
Leadership from the top is essential
For many companies, meeting their responsibility to respect human rights as outlined in the Guiding Principles often involves a process of change management in which leadership from the top – including the board – is essential.
Senior management has a unique role to play in signalling the importance of human rights to the business. In their speeches, senior managers’ messages, corporate communications and in their personal conversations, top management can urge and demonstrate leadership in addressing human rights as part of the company’s values.
Helpful guidance for board directors can be found in the UK Equality and Human Rights Commission’s 2016 publication ‘Business and human rights: A five-step guide for company boards’.
❖ Examples from practice
At The Coca-Cola Company, on Human Rights Day (10 December) each year, a special message is shared with all employees on human rights via email and/or the company’s intranet. The message re-emphasises the importance of the company’s commitment to respect human rights and highlights the company’s actions on the implementation of the UN Guiding Principles in the past year. This has helped demonstrate that human rights is a topic that the company is committed to, and highlights new challenges, as well as yearly progress, for those employees who are not involved in the company’s human rights efforts on a day-to-day basis.
Click here for more on The Coca-Cola Company’s human rights embedding journey and its aim to have every employee think about how their everyday actions relate to human rights, including a short video with employee perspectives.
Considering the company’s commitment in recruitment
Companies are often keen to ensure that the individuals they hire embrace the company’s values – including respect for human rights. Applicants could be asked how they intend to balance respect for company values with other business pressures, and how they have grappled with such dilemmas in the past. For example, a prospective bank employee could be asked what they would do if they became aware that one of the bank’s sales agents was acting in a discriminatory manner towards clients.
Of course, companies also need to recruit people with the right skills: for example, a common misconception by companies is that anyone can ‘do’ community engagement because ‘it’s just talking to people’. Yet experience demonstrates that planning, conducting and managing successful engagement with local communities requires a particular skill set and expertise. This is further discussed on the chapter on Engaging with Stakeholders.
Talking honestly about human rights
Embedding respect for human rights means avoiding excessive ‘happy talk’ about how well the company is doing in meeting its commitments, and speaking honestly about the challenges and how it can improve. Companies have found various ways to encourage more in-depth discussion, including:
- Developing an internal human rights guide that describes how the company approaches human rights, and actual cases where staff have faced human rights challenges (see examples in the box below);
- Making such internal guidance available externally so that other stakeholders can understand how the company handles tough situations, beyond the high-level statements contained in its public policy;
- Developing human rights dilemmas based on real experiences that staff can work through in an interactive setting, discussing how they would handle such cases;
- Sharing challenges and good practice in addressing them across the company via the intranet and presentations;
- Exposing staff to settings where they can see human rights impacts first-hand, for example, when visiting subsidiaries, clients or suppliers, or through photos or video presentations when such in-person exposure is not feasible.
Training key staff
Many companies train their staff in the company’s business principles or code of conduct. Such training can include discussion of human rights dilemmas. Tailored training should be provided for staff who encounter particular human rights dilemmas (for example, procurement personnel who are often dealing with business pressures related to price and delivery time, as well as social performance) or who operate in challenging human rights situations (for example, contexts where there is systematic abuse of the human rights of certain groups). Training should be reviewed regularly to assess if it is effective in helping them achieve their goal.
Developing incentives and disincentives
Reward and recognition systems should be expanded to include respect for human rights. They should be reviewed to ensure that they do not incentivise the wrong behaviour – for example, if procurement staff are paid a bonus when suppliers meet tight deadlines to deliver products faster to meet a business goal, but are only able to do so by requiring their workers to take on excessive or unpaid overtime. It is also important that failures to respect human rights have appropriate internal consequences.
Some examples of incentive systems include:
- Requiring at least one goal related to human rights to be included in the goals of all managers;
- Tying bonuses for human rights performance to a group or team’s joint efforts;
- Making respect for human rights part of the competences framework against which employees are evaluated.
❖ Examples: committees supporting human rights decision-making
PT Holcim Indonesia has a steering committee (CEO, Legal Director & HR Director) to guide the implementation of human rights policies, such as supplier self-assessment studies.
Provides a channel for employees to ask for advice on issues related to the company’s code of conduct, which explicitly refers to human rights. It can scalate an issue or case to the Ethics Committee, chaired by the CEO, which also “commissions reviews of existing policy and guidelines,” while its “recommendations [serve] as a guiding principle for people’s actions within the organisation”.
Plays a central role in the company’s governance and embedding of respect of human rights. It drives awareness, supports a network of ethics officers throughout the company and has an Ethics Panel that “deals with all material tipoffs regarding unethical conduct and now reports to [a board committee] in its continued efforts to ensure that independent, objective and fair courses of action are taken in instances of unethical behaviour or actions”.
Dewan ini diwakili oleh berbagai departemen dan fungsi, memiliki tanggung jawab utama untuk memproses dan menyetujui penjualan sesuai dengan uji tuntas HAM dalam kebebasan berekspresi dan hak atas privasi. Dalam beberapa kasus, dewan dapat merekomendasikan asesmen dampak HAM di negara-negara tertentu. Bila perlu, Proses Kepatuhan Penjualan menentukan apakah tindakan mitigasi harus dilakukan.
Developing capacity to solve dilemmas and respond to unforeseen circumstances
Company decisions that involve human rights often present difficult dilemmas, and capacity is needed to deal with them. A growing number of companies have created a committee that addresses human rights-related dilemmas such as an ethics, integrity or corporate responsibility committee. The committee’s functions can include:
- Providing interpretation and application of business principles or the code of conduct, including any human rights commitments;
- Discussing dilemmas arising within the company (for example, whether company values can be upheld in a major new contract, or whether a new country should be entered);
- Reviewing company-wide complaints procedures and making recommendations on how to strengthen them.
Common pitfalls to avoid
Isolation of human rights into a single department
When building internal capacity on human rights, companies have found that the rest of the business may feel less responsibility for human rights if human rights are seen to be ‘taken care of’ by a particular individual or function. A company needs to balance the development of internal expertise with the need for shared ownership of the management of human rights impacts.
Staff with responsibility for human rights lack access
Those with responsibility for human rights need access to all relevant parts of the company, and an awareness of events relevant to human rights within the company, so that they can effectively translate human rights for the business.
Setting counterproductive incentives
If performance targets are linked solely to reducing the number of human rights-related incidents, instead of stimulating openness and a willingness to improve, this may result in reduced reporting of incidents rather than an actual reduction of incidents. It is important that incentives stimulate the right behaviour rather than superficially good metrics.
Some suggestions for SMEs
Easier cross-functional coordination
In smaller companies, it is often impossible to have a full-time person working on one particular topic. At the same time, there may be a simpler hierarchy and communication structure, making it easier for different staff with different human rights responsibilities to coordinate their efforts.
Participate in organised training
Instead of developing their own training, companies can take part in programmes offered by organisations that provide training. The Business & Human Rights Resource Centre has a running list of events, including open courses.
Ensuring tone at the top
Like larger companies, this is critically important. For SMEs that are run by their founder, it may be relatively easier to ensure values-based messaging.
Benefit from more informal communication with workers
Management within SMEs can often engage directly with workers more easily than management in larger companies can. This can help in communicating about the importance of human rights, as well as enabling management to hear directly what challenges staff are experiencing in practice in meeting the commitment.
- Business & Human Rights Resource Centre: Daftar Kebijakan HAM Perusahaan: www.business-humanrights.org/Documents/Policies.
- ELSAM dan Komnas HAM (2017), “Rencana Aksi Nasional Bisnis dan HAM”. Jakarta: Komnas HAM.
- Global Compact, “Global Compact 2018 Progress Report: Asia Pacific Analysis”, 2018.
- Inisiatif Bisnis dan HAM (2010), “Bagaimana Menjalankan Bisnis dengan Menghormati HAM: Sebuah Alat Panduan bagi Perusahaan,” Den Haag: Global Compact Network Netherlands
- INFID, “Kertas Kebijakan: Menuju Implementasi Prinsip-Prinsip Panduan PBB tentang Bisnis dan HAM di Indonesia”, 2018.
- Kementerian Luar Negeri Republik Indonesia, “Panduan Bisnis dan HAM”. 2018.
- Shift, ‘Embedding Respect for Human Rights Within a Company’s Operations’, 2012.
- Shift, Oxfam and Global Compact Network Netherlands, “Doing Business with Respect for Human Rights: A Guidance Tool for Companies”, 2016.
- UN Global Compact, ‘Good Practice Note on Organizing the Human Rights Function within a Company’, 2014.
- Ilustrasi: www.freepik.com